Education library
Available nowGuide

Judging Standards & Scoring

How LTP frames consistent, defensible scoring — the principles behind a rubric, and how to apply it to a field of competitors.

  • Judges

What this guide covers

  1. 01Scoring principles
  2. 02Applying a rubric consistently
  3. 03Writing comments that hold up

Judging is a responsibility before it is an opinion. Consistent, defensible scoring protects the contestants, the system, and the judge, and it is built from the same few habits at every event.

What consistent scoring means

Consistency means the same standard is applied to every contestant in a phase, and that a score can be explained afterwards by pointing to what happened on stage. It does not mean scoring everyone the same. It means your reasons are visible, and they do not change depending on who is in front of you.

Before the competition

Read the system's rules in full: the phases, the weightings, the tie-breaker, and any eligibility restrictions. Confirm with the director how the scores are captured, and whether the panel calibrates together on the range to use. Agree what a mid-range score means before you see the first contestant.

  • Disclose any relationship with a contestant and recuse if the system requires it.
  • Ask where comments are recorded and who reads them.
  • Put your phone away for the duration of the event.

During the competition

Score each phase as it ends, while the details are fresh, rather than saving everything for the final deliberation. Note one specific reason for each score. If you can only write 'good stage presence', the note is not yet useful to anyone.

Watch for the halo effect: one strong phase quietly lifting every later score. Judge each phase against its own criteria. Avoid comparing a contestant to the person who came before them, and never comment on a contestant's body, wardrobe cost, or anything they cannot change in a week.

Writing comments that hold up

Describe behaviour and its effect, then say what would have strengthened it. 'Your answer wandered before reaching the point, so the panel had to work to follow it; leading with the outcome would land harder' can be read by a contestant without harm. A comment that reads as a verdict on a person cannot.

After the competition

Review the spread of your scores before the panel finalises. A range that is entirely narrow, or entirely wide, is usually a sign you drifted rather than a sign of the field. If you are asked to explain a decision, explain the criteria you applied, not the outcome you preferred.

Last updated November 2026.

All education resources